9 Best Jeffree Star Unicorn Blood Dupes





This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This doesn't affect the opinions or assessments of our editors.


Last Updated: October 20, 2021

Whether you’ve decided to stop supporting Jeffree Star for various reasons or just want a cheaper alternative, one things for sure: you’re going to need some Jeffree Star Unicorn Blood dupes, quick.

Don’t worry, we’ve compiled some of the best dupes out there that will make you completely forget about Unicorn Blood (including affordable options as well as a few higher-end options)!

NYX Liquid Suede Lipstick in Cherry Skies

Not only is the NYX liquid suede lipstick one of the top drugstore liquid lipsticks out there, they also have a dupe for Unicorn Blood – “Cherry Skies!”

Not only is the color pretty close, the formula feels fantastic and this lipstick lasts forever. And best of all, it costs less than $10!


Colourpop Ultra Matte Lip in Avenue

Colourpop is another top name when it comes to liquid lipsticks.

Their “Avenue” shade of Ultra Matte Lip is another great dupe that replicates the deep red we all love in Unicorn Blood. The formula is excellent and stays on your lips forever (although some people find it a little drying, so make sure to moisturize your lips).

Side note: LAX is a pretty similar shade as well.


Ofra Havana Nights

Although not the most affordable option, Havana Nights from Ofra Cosmetics is another very close dupe for Unicorn Blood.

This brick-red lipstick has a matte finish and a long-lasting formula that’s definitely worth investing in.


Beauty Creations Malevolent 

This lipstick can be hard to find in popular stores, but well worth it if you can get your hands on it.

It’s pretty affordable (typically around $5) and the formula will surprise you. It lasts a long time without being overly drying. Plus, the color is spot-on!


Lime Crime Wicked

Although this lipstick is usually even more expensive than Jeffree Star’s Unicorn Blood, it’s worth trying out if you’re looking for alternatives.

The formula is silky smooth, non-drying, and seems to last forever. There’s a reason Lime Crime is one of the top liquid lipsticks!


Anastasia Beverly Hills Heathers

This matte liquid lipstick from ABH is another close match for Unicorn Blood. It’s long-wearing, waterproof, smudge-resistant, and non-drying.

There are a ton of colors, but “Heathers” seems to be the closest match.


Kat Von D Liquid Lipstick in Vampira

When comparing Vampira and Unicorn Blood side-by-side, it’s almost impossible to tell the difference. Plus, this is one of the best performing liquid lipsticks out there!

Although this is actually a little bit more expensive than Jeffree Star’s lipstick, it’s a great choice if you’re simply looking for a different brand.


MAC Liquid Lipcolor in High Drama

We all love a good lipstick from MAC. Now, you can get your Unicorn Blood dupe from this high-quality brand as well!

This deep red is a very similar shade with a similar feel and performance as well!


Black Moon Cosmetics Deranged

To finish off our list of Jeffree Star Unicorn Blood dupes, this lipstick is another great alternative. It’s often sold out, but if you can catch it when they restock, you’ll be pleased with the performance.

The formula is smooth, long-lasting, non-drying, and overall impressive. And, the color is one of the closest matches we’ve found for Unicorn Blood.

UP NEXT: 10 Best Lipstick Brands to Try