6 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils for Perfect Brows





We may earn a commission from links on our website, but this doesn't influence the opinions of our editors.

Last Updated: May 17, 2022

Eyebrow pencils are one of those makeup products that can get expensive, especially if you like retractable pencils. These run out pretty quickly. Luckily, there are drugstore eyebrow pencils that work just as well as luxury products (maybe even better)!

Today, we’ll be sharing some of the top-rated and best drugstore eyebrow pencil products to help you pick your next holy grail product without overspending.


NYX Microbrow Eyebrow Pencil

Our overall winner for the best drugstore eyebrow pencil is the famous NYX Microbrow. This retractable pencil lasts all day without smudging or fading and blends in wonderfully with your real eyebrows.

It’s great for filling in sparse areas of any size! This is double-sided with the brow pencil on one side and an eyebrow brush on the other side to help you stay manicured.


Sephora Retractable Brow Pencil

Although not technically available in drugstores, this eyebrow pencil from the Sephora brand is inexpensive and has great results.

It costs $12, but you can often find it on sale for a comparable cost to other drugstore eyebrow pencils.


e.l.f Ultra Precise Brow Pencil

If you’re all about deals, e.l.f is where it’s at. This brand is very affordable and has plenty of surprisingly effective products!

This retractable fine-point brow pencil costs $5 and comes with an eyebrow brush on one end. The fine tip makes it easy to design your brows exactly the way you dream. If you want an even cheaper option, check out the pencil below.


e.l.f Instant Lift Brow Pencil

While there are a lot of opportunities to go wrong with a $2 eyebrow pencil, this one works surprisingly well. It’s not as fine-tip as the previous pencil, but you might prefer this.

Available in 5 different shades, this pencil is double-ended with a retractable brow pencil on one side and an eyebrow brush on the other side. This helps you replicate a lash lift without spending $100+ on treatments!

RELATED: 11 Best Eyebrow Tints For Flawless Brows


LA Girl Shady Slim Brow Pencil

Available in 9 different shades, this drugstore brow pencil costs $6 (they often have sales that bring this price even lower). And let us tell you, it’s worth every penny!

The skinny tip helps you create thin strokes with easily, ensuring your brows look natural and full (not fake). Again, this one has a brush to tame unruly brows.


essence Eyebrow Designer

To finish off our best eyebrow pencil list, the essence Eyebrow Designer is worth a mention (especially if you’re not a fan of retractable pencils). This one costs only $2 and lasts forever!

They’ve done an excellent job at creating colors that match any brow shade. The soft formula is perfect for creating natural-looking eyebrows in minutes.

Note: “Auburn” is a popular color for matching Strawberry Blonde hair.

UP NEXT: 10 Best Eyebrow Makeup Products