Watch Gang Review: Should You Try This Watch Subscription?





We may earn a commission from links on our website, but this doesn't influence the opinions of our editors.

Last Updated: March 1, 2022

Trying to decide on a watch subscription service? Check out our Watch Gang review to see if this box is worth it!

Watches are a beautiful accessory for everyone. From luxury to simplicity, you can never go wrong with a good watch. But how do you go about starting a collection when you don’t know what you want or you’re on a budget? That’s where Watch Gang can help. They choose watches for you based on your personal style & help you create your own valuable collection at a more affordable price. Today, we’re going to share our Watch Gang review to see if they’re truly all that they are made out to be!

What is Watch Gang?

Watch Gang is a men’s subscription service for high-quality watches from top brands. First started in 2016, Watch Gang has grown to be a popular service loved by many.

Best of all, you get to keep every watch you receive! With watches guaranteed to be worth more than your membership fee, this subscription is a great way for any watch-lover to expand their collection while also getting watches worth more than they pay. It also makes a great gift!

The origin of Watch Gang started at a young age for the founder (Matthew Gallagher). As a kid, he had a deep fascination for technology and nerdy things.

Watches were always just a cool accessory until his father passed down his vintage watch upon his death. From there, Matthew realized just how much a watch can truly do for someone and started Watch Gang, a universal selection of unique watches for everyone. 

Is Watch Gang Legit?

Yes, we’ve received multiple high-quality watches that were valued well above the monthly subscription cost. We feel that it’s currently the best watch subscription company out.

Watch Gang Prices

You can select from either a monthly plan or quarterly plan (receive a watch every 3 months). They offer three membership tiers to fit anyone’s price range:

  • Original Tier: $49.99 / month for watch worth up to $150
  • Black Tier: $99.99 / month for watch worth up to $500
  • Platinum Tier: $299.99 / month for watch worth up to $1,500
  • Centum Tier: Invite-only program (pay $1,000 to $1,500 for watches valued at a few thousand)

To get started with Watch Gang is pretty simple. Upon registering, you will be asked a series of questions. This questionnaire helps gather your style and then they will pick watches based on your answers.

Note: You don’t have the option to pick out your own watches, so make sure to fill out this quiz as accurately as possible! You can also view their previously featured watches.

After taking the quiz, you will then be asked to select a plan. After this, your first unique watch will be shipped within three business days and arrive at your doorstep shortly after!

Something else worth noting is that you may be a lucky winner of a giveaway of a Rolex, Seiko, or Tag watch! Watch Gang runs three giveaways per week. They also do this secretly so that you aren’t expecting anything when you get your order. Pretty cool, right?

RELATED: 11 Best Entry Level Designer Watches


Watch Gang Reviews

Watch Gang Original Tier Review

Check out: Past months’ Original Tier watches

If you’re just getting into watch collecting this is the perfect place to start! You can start off by getting some cheaper pieces, this will help you determine what type of watches you truly love.

The good thing about Watch Gang is that you will be getting a quality piece regardless of the tier you choose. The main difference I feel is the style and mechanics.


Watch Gang Black Tier Review

Check out: Past months’ Black Tier watches

If you’ve already started a small collection and are looking to add some mid-level watches to it, this is where I suggest you go.

I found that the watches I received in the Black Tier subscription were definitely higher quality than the original tier watches.

Although not the most expensive in my collection, a few of these watches actually made their way into my top favorite watches.


Watch Gang Platinum Tier Review

Check out: Past months’ Platinum Tier watches

This personally was my favorite Tier simply due to the quality of watches that I received. If you’re a serious collector I suggest giving this a shot.

I felt like I got a watch that was worth more than what I paid for the monthly subscription.


Overall: ★★★★ 4 stars

All in all, there are plenty of happy customers when it comes to Watch Gang. There are some customers, however, who state that the watches are of lesser value than they pay.

Price: ★★★★ 4 stars

The price for the subscription, especially for the Original Tier, is pretty affordable for watches. Their subscription starts at just $49 and goes up to $299.

Quality: ★★★★ 4 stars

While some customers are happy with the quality of the watches they received, other customers say the quality was poor and not worth the money.

Value: ★★★★ 4 stars

Some customers complained that the value of the watches they received was either the same or of less value than what they paid.

Watch Gang Customer Reviews

Having searched through hundreds of Watch Gang reviews, we’ve pulled some of the top feedback shared by multiple members to help give you a more accurate representation of what people typically experience with this company.

“I’m loving Watch Gang. Getting a surprise watch each month isn’t for me since I’m so picky about what I wear. So, I’ve purchased $2140 in points for the wheel spins and feel great about what I’m getting for the dollars spent. No regrets thus far!” – J Adams

“Happy so far! I just received my first watch yesterday and was very happy with it. I see there are several complaints about the value of the watch, but the watch I received retails for quite a bit more than my membership.” – AJ H.

“I signed up for a few watches before I did research. They shipped me two low-value watches for $285.95 total. The “MSRP” they claim is grossly inflated.” – Brandon P.

Overall, here are the main points of feedback based on other Watch Gang reviews:

  • A lot of customers are happy with their surprise watches
  • Some customers say the value of the watches is overexaggerated
  • Good service for those exploring their options or just starting out
  • Reddit users are particulary critical, reporting poor quality and negative reviews about the wheel

Return Policy

Now, what happens if you get your watch and you don’t absolutely love it?

The big downside to WatchGang is that if you receive a watch you don’t love, they actually do not offer returns or exchanges.

This is definitely something to keep in mind before committing to a subscription with them. However, they do suggest that if you aren’t happy with the watches you’ve been receiving, you can check out their ‘Wheel of Watches‘ to help you have better control of what watches you will receive. So, that’s a plus at least. 

Bottomline: Is Watch Gang Worth It? 

To sum up our Watch Gang review, it’s hard to say if Watch Gang is for you or not. We love the concept of the brand, but so many other reviews stated that they overinflated the value of their watches. However, many other people were very happy with their subscription, so it’s worth trying out yourself.

It also might not be the best fit for you if you’re super picky about what you wear since they don’t let you pick anything out for yourself, but the risk can be minimized by using their ‘Wheel Spin‘ feature.

Watch Gang Alternatives

If you don’t think Watch Gang is for you, here are some alternatives that you might consider trying:

  1. The Watch Studio
  2. Wrist Monthly
  3. Breitling Select

UP NEXT: 17 Stylish Watch Boxes For Stylish Storage