We may earn a commission from links on our website, but this doesn't influence the opinions of our editors.

Makeup Eraser Reviews: Time to Cancel Makeup Remover?

Last Updated: October 12, 2022

Makeup wipes are the majority’s go-to for removing makeup, but do you ever wonder what those wipes are even made of? The answer isn’t usually good. The Makeup Eraser is a sustainable and travel-friendly washcloth that can remove your makeup with only water.    

It was hard to believe, so I had to give it a shot. I was so over the irritation of makeup wipes, and also couldn’t shake the thought of aging when I dragged my own skin! Here are my honest Makeup Eraser reviews of this new beauty product that’s taking over social media.  

What is the Makeup Eraser? 

The brand was started in 2013 by Elexis McCarthy. She had always had a passion for sustainability and quickly realized her idea for the antimicrobial towel needed to be shared with the world.  

She developed a makeup erasing towel that uses no chemicals, no oils, and no parabens to remove makeup; thus creating a product that would not harm the Earth. Now, Makeup Eraser is dermatologist-approved and friendly for all skin types (even sensitive skin)!

It’s easy to use, simply get it wet and wipe your makeup off. You use the short fiber side to remove makeup, then flip to the longer fiber side that has the tag to pick up any leftover makeup and exfoliate your skin.

It’s best to wash it once a week, which is very easy to do (just throw it in the washing machine). 

Makeup Eraser Overview

The Original Makeup Eraser is sold for $20 a towel and comes in 11 different shades. They also have plenty of other limited-edition collections, such as the Printed and others you can find in their New Arrivals.

There are holiday, animals, and seasonal-themed 7-day sets that come in a pack of small towels made for everyday use. These typically cost $25. You can also choose the package free option to purchase the towels on their own for $8. 

My Makeup Eraser Reviews 

I am a die-hard advocate of the cotton rounds with micellar water makeup removal, but Makeup Eraser did show me a different side to it all. 

Overall: ★★★★★ 5 stars

I found that with the Makeup Eraser, it took me way less time and waste to remove my face than with cotton rounds and makeup remover. Usually, I have to use almost 10 cotton rounds to do the job.

It was so soft and gentle on my skin, though I was a bit irritated around my eye area. The towel glides smoothly across your skin, really doing a great job at removal in a single swipe. The process was almost effortless! 

Price: ★★★★ 4 stars

At $20 per Eraser, this might seem kind of pricey. However, this is a high-quality product that will save you a lot of money in the long run by not having to buy disposable makeup wipes anymore!

Quality: ★★★★★ 5 stars

Overall, the quality of the Makeup Eraser is top-notch. It somehow erases all traces of makeup with just water. It’s like magic.

Value: ★★★★★ 5 stars

The Makeup Eraser is a great value since it’s a great product that will end up saving you some money. The sets are especially valuable at just $25 for 7 of them.

Original Pink Makeup Eraser Review


This original pink Makeup Eraser is what started it all. It can remove the toughest makeup including waterproof mascara.

Use the short fiber side to remove your makeup, then flip it over and use the long fiber side to exfoliate. It’s machine washable and can last up to five years!

7-Day Sets Review


These 7-day sets are not only super valuable, but they also come in a bunch of fun designs, like this Disney Villian set!

They are also double-sided, machine washable, and long-lasting. They are a little smaller than the original Makeup Eraser to make for easier travel.

What Customers Are Saying

The Makeup Eraser reviews across the web are overwhelmingly positive, including from sites like Trustpilot and Sitejabber. Overall, here is what customers had to say about the Original Makeup Eraser as a whole:

  • Highly effective
  • Great quality
  • Good for sensitve skin
  • Easy to clean
  • Some say you can buy generic brands that work just as well

Return Policy

If you aren’t happy with your purchase, Makeup Eraser provides a 100% money-back guarantee within 30 days of your purchase. 

You can simply call their number or email their sales department and the return will be processed.

Bottom Line

To sum up my Makeup Eraser reviews, I am definitely going to recommend this cloth to my friends. Not only was it gentle and easy, but sustainability is another great feature of this product. There is nothing better than knowing you are helping the environment! Also, I just can’t resist all of the cute packaging in the different collections.

Available on Amazon, Ulta, Sephora, Nordstrom Rack, or the Makeup Eraser website, this is an easily accessible product that everyone should try out.

UP NEXT: 13 Best Sustainable Clothing Brands for a “Green” Wardrobe