5 Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes – Top Alternatives





Last Updated: October 12, 2021

If you’ve tried the Better Than Sex Mascara from Too Faced, you know the excellent plumping and lengthening effects this mascara shows for most people. But, if you don’t love the price tag of the Better Than Sex Mascara, dupes can be a great alternative!

Luckily, there are a few top-performing dupes that are a fraction of the price tag.

We’ve tested 10+ options and found these winners. Although not exact dupes and they won’t give the same results for everyone, these are the top results.

Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes

L’Oréal Lash Paradise

One of the top-rated dupes, L’Oreal Lash Paradise even looks like its competitor! If you’re wondering what to try first, definitely give this mascara a shot. It may very well end up being your new holy grail!

This mascara offers similar lengthening and volumizing results for dramatic lashes you’ll fall in love with – no flakes or spider lashes!


Covergirl Flamed Out

With a similar brush style, a lot of makeup gurus are turning to Covergirl Flamed Out mascara as a dupe.

Note: This formula tends to be a little more drying than the Better Than Sex formula. Some people like the Covergirl Clump Crusher better, so you might want to look into both options!


Rimmel ScandalEyes Retro Glam

This one is a hit or miss, but it can definitely be worth trying out if the other two above don’t work out or you want something even cheaper.

It features a similar brush and creates those bold, long lashes that you’ve been craving. When purchasing, make sure to get the “Retro Glam” as this is the best one in our opinion.


Jordana Best Lash Extreme

Another comparable mascara to Better Than Sex, this affordable option from Jordana is another top pick by those look for dupes that are as affordable as can be.

That said, it can be hard to find in stores or online, so you might need to do some extra searching if you really want to try this one.


Essence Lash Princess

Talking about affordable, the Essence Lash Princess is believe to be a dupe for Better Than Sex by a ton of users. It does a beautiful job at lengthening and adding extra volume to lashes.

At $5, this one is definitely worth giving a try.


Lancome Hypnose Drama

This one is actually a few bucks more expensive than Better Than Sex, but it’s a great dupe if you don’t like the longetivity of Better Than Sex (some people notice smudging or flaking).

This mascara provides similar effects while also lasting all day long!