13 Best Cream Eyeshadows for Long-Lasting Pigment





Last Updated: July 18, 2021

It can be fun to add a bit of personality to your eyelids with a touch (or more) of color. However, along with using powder eyeshadow often comes cleaning up dusty residue left behind by your eyeshadow palette. 

Fortunately, cream shadows provide an easy-to apply and dust-free alternative to traditional palettes. You can even use the tip of your finger to add the pigment to your lids. 

Cream shadows create a smooth finish, don’t crack, and don’t clump-up in dry areas. Best of all, they’re easier to blend, gliding smoothly onto the skin even if you forget to use a primer.

Convinced yet? Check out these 12 best cream eyeshadows to add to your beauty collection.  

Best Cream Eyeshadows

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow Stick 

With a total of 17 colors to choose from, this cream shadow stick is easy to apply and long-lasting. 

It’s also waterproof, making it perfect for any outing whether you’re sweating it out in the summer heat or staying close to the AC. With hundreds of 5-star reviews at Sephora, this product is definitely a must-have.


RMS Eye Polish Cream Eyeshadow

If you’re looking for a more neutral look when it comes to eyeshadow, RMS offers some beautiful natural shades in their eye polish collection. 

It’s a natural-based cream eyeshadow formulated with coconut oil, jojoba oil, and vitamin E to moisture the skin and give it a pop of color at the same time.


Mac Pro Long-Wear Paint Pot Eyeshadow

This Mac product has rich, creatively-named shades like “Black Mirror” and “Contemplative State.” Best of all, there’s a whole 22 colors to choose from, each with a seamless, blendable finish. 

Highly-pigmented and long-wearing, your eyes are sure to pop throughout the day. 


E.L.F No-Budge Shadow Stick 

With a single-swipe application, a shimmery finish, and a no-budge formula, it’s hard to go wrong with this E.L.F product. 

Purchase at your local drugstore and stock up with plenty of colors—this stick comes in 7 beautiful shades.


Hourglass Scattered Light Glitter Eye Shadow

Make your eyes pop with this standout, super-glittery cream eyeshadow from Hourglass. 

Made with refined micro-glitter and light-reflecting pearls, go big with an eyeshadow look that’s not only bold, but comfortable and lightweight as well. 


Milk Makeup Eye Pigment

This fun cream eyeshadow comes in a variety of vivid colors from royal blue to bright purple. One of the longest-latest cream shadows in the game, this eye pigment from Milk won’t budge for your whole night out.

Plus, the tube it comes in is super convenient to carry for on-the-go application.


NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil

Use this stick as an eyeshadow, a liner, or even a highlighter for the corners of your eyes. 

Not only is it multipurpose, it also glides on effortlessly and quickly, cutting down your morning prep time. 


Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow

Applying a cream eyeshadow doesn’t get easier than with this eyeshadow stick from Laura Mercier. 

WIth a wide range of colors from pretty neutrals to vibrant purples, this is the perfect eyeshadow to set and forget. All you need is a quick swipe on your eyelids for all-day wear. 


Tom Ford Cream Color For Eyes

Looking to add some metallic shimmer in your makeup look? Try this creamy, highly-pigmented eyeshadow from Tom Ford. 

Not only is it smudge-proof and crease-proof, it also gives your eyelids a 3D pop of color that you can take from day to night. 


Au Naturale The Anywhere Cream Multistick 

As the name suggests, this product can be applied anywhere on your face…literally. 

Wherever you want to add a splash of color, whether that’s your lips, your cheeks, or lids, simply use your cream multistick and blend! 


Alleyoop 11th Hour Cream Eyeshadow Stick 

No brushes needed with this eyeshadow stick! With 7 matte colors, this product has a creamy, crease-proof finish

Best of all, you only need to apply once throughout your day as this shadow is also resistant to smudging. 


Bare Minerals 5-in-1 BB Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow

Not only is this eyeshadow super pigmented, it also offers SPF coverage that you may not normally get on your eyelids as well as extra skincare benefits. 

Working to smooth the appearance of fine lines, this product will ensure a colorful, creaseless finish. 


Glossier Lidstar

Last but not least, Glossier’s Lidstar is truly a star. This product has a few lighter, shimmery colors to choose from that are essential for any eyeshadow collection!

With a long-lasting finish and easily blendable formula, you can’t go wrong with this Glossier product.

RELATED: How to Apply Eyeshadow 101: The Ultimate Guide

The Bottom Line

Cream eyeshadows offer extraordinary benefits! They often help you create seamless, pigmented finishes with easy-to-blend formulas. 

Next time you want to add a pop of color to your makeup look, check out one of these best cream eyeshadows to get the job done!